Sica | Fletcher Market Intelligence + Leaders & Legends Podcast Series
Insurance Broker Valuations Gone Wild
Insurance brokerage valuations are diverging sharply, with some smaller firms commanding higher multiples than larger public peers. Sica | Fletcher explores how buyer incentives, investment timelines, and pressure to deploy capital are driving these gaps beyond traditional measures of size and risk.
Insurance Broker Valuations: What Is The Right Multiple?
Podcast 1: Leaders & Legends Podcast Featuring John Hahn, Chairman of Galway Holdings and Tom O’Neil, Vice Chairman of EPIC Brokers & Consultants
John Hahn of Galway Holdings and Tom O’Neil of EPIC join Al Sica to discuss building long-term growth through specialization, integration, and strategic acquisitions. They also explore private equity, industry consolidation, and how AI can improve efficiency while preserving client relationships.
Podcast 2: Leaders & Legends Podcast Featuring Jim Burr, Co-Head of Global Financial Services Carlyle
Carlyle’s Jim Burr joins Al Sica to discuss what makes insurance brokerages attractive to investors and why organic growth, strong leadership, and integration drive long-term value. He explains how cultural alignment and operational performance build value beyond acquisitions, and how Carlyle partners with management teams to strengthen businesses and prepare for future ownership opportunities. Burr also explores AI’s potential to improve productivity while reinforcing the importance of human relationships.
Find more insights here: https://www.sicafletcher.com/market-intelligence
and podcasts here: https://www.sicafletcher.com/sica-fletcher-podcasts
All opinions expressed by the host and guests are their own and are not necessarily those of Sica | Fletcher. This podcast is for informational purposes only and should not be relied upon as professional advice. Sica | Fletcher employees and clients may have positions in the firms discussed in this podcast. Any information provided herein is indicative only, subject to change, and does not constitute an offer to purchase or sell any financial product. Sica | Fletcher LLC does not underwrite securities, nor advise on, nor effect transactions in securities for the account of others.


